Vinyl vs laminate flooring comparison

Is vinyl plank a better choice than laminate flooring?

When comparing vinyl vs laminate flooring, both options are attractive and easy to install. The ‘better choice’ is subjective and depends on your preferences. Both offer an advantage over the other in different areas.

The qualities of vinyl flooring

Vinyl flooring sheets and tiles are typically made of a fibreglass base coated with PVC vinyl and a plasticizer. The surface print layer can mimic hardwood flooring, stone, porcelain, and just about any design or material you can think of. Overtop of the print layer is multiple wear layers for protection and durability. Luxury vinyl plank flooring is made of thicker, multiple-layer PVC vinyl and interlocks side-to-side for easy installation.

The qualities of laminate flooring

Laminate flooring is quite similar to luxury vinyl planks with the main difference being that the core of laminate flooring is made from wood products bonded with resins. The print layer is covered with a durable and transparent plastic wear layer.

To help you choose the right flooring option for you, we’ve created this vinyl vs laminate flooring comparison guide based on common factors that customers are looking for.

  • Best for water resistance: vinyl
  • Best for maintenance: vinyl
  • Best for appearance: laminate
  • Best for comfort and sound: laminate
  • Best for durability: vinyl
  • Best for environmental impact: laminate
Vinyl vs Laminate flooring
Vinyl vs Laminate flooring

Water Resistance

If you’re looking for water-resistant flooring, vinyl is your ideal choice. If installed correctly, vinyl can withstand high-moisture conditions or where water can be prevalent, including bathrooms, kitchens, mudrooms, and basements. It won’t warp or buckle like hardwood flooring.

Laminate flooring, on the other hand, is more susceptible to damage from moisture and standing water. Because its core is made with a wood product, moisture can cause laminate flooring to buckle, warp, and separate. The design layer can also peel away with water damage.

Maintenance

Both vinyl and laminate flooring don’t require finishing or need special precautions for maintenance like other flooring types. Vinyl plank is an easy floor to clean with a mild cleanser and a traditional mop. Avoid using a steam mop to clean vinyl flooring.

Laminate flooring is also easy to maintain. However, it’s important not to use a wet mop on laminate and wipe up any spills as soon as possible. A broom or dust mop on laminate is all you need for a good clean!

Appearance

Vinyl vs laminate difference in appearance has to do with the design layer. While vinyl plank flooring allows for deeper embossing, laminate’s surface print layer will more closely mimic hardwood, ceramic, stone, and other designs.

Comfort and sound

Again, because the core of laminate flooring is made of wood content, it’s slightly more comfortable than vinyl flooring. When combined with a quality underlayment, laminate provides a more quiet and comfortable surface for high foot traffic and young children compared to vinyl.

Durability

Unlike hardwood, vinyl and laminate flooring are both resistant to scratches and dents and relatively easy to repair if damaged. When comparing vinyl vs laminate differences in durability, vinyl has a slight edge because of its water-resistant properties.
Environmental impact

When it comes to vinyl vs laminate flooring, neither of these materials can offer the sustainability of natural wood or bamboo flooring. However, because laminate’s fibreboard core contains natural wood, it has a slight edge compared to vinyl.

Recent Blogs

Flooring Store in Calgary - Deerfoot Carpet

4 Flooring Options That Work Well Over Concrete Substrate

When selecting the perfect flooring for your basement, there can be many options to pick from. If you have concrete substrate, you have no shortage of options, from laminate to hardwood, vinyl flooring, and much more. It can be difficult to filter through all your choices and find the most ideal for your home.

When you visit any flooring store in Calgary, it’s reasonable to feel a little overwhelmed by the amount of inventory.

Read more
Pros & Cons of Vinyl Plank Flooring

Pros & Cons of Vinyl Plank Flooring

Vinyl flooring has become an increasingly popular choice for homeowners in recent years with its practicality and versatility. Available in many styles, such as vinyl planks, sheets, and luxury vinyl tile, you can tailor your home aesthetics to your personal taste.

However, as with all significant home improvements, understanding the benefits and drawbacks of vinyl plank flooring is crucial before selecting. This guide provides a comprehensive breakdown of the pros and cons to determine if vinyl flooring fits your needs and space.

Read more
Laminate vs Vinyl Flooring

Laminate vs Vinyl Flooring: Key Differences + Pros & Cons

Both vinyl and laminate flooring present a range of attractive benefits, including resilience, aesthetic appeal, cost-effectiveness, and user-friendly installation. At a glance, the two types of flooring can even appear almost identical.

However, it’s important to note that neither flooring type is categorically superior to the other. The ideal choice depends on your specific needs and circumstances. In this article, Deerfoot Carpet & Flooring will examine the major differences between laminate flooring and vinyl flooring.

Read more

Experience the
Deerfoot Advantage

  • Largest inventory in-stock, that means no waiting for your product to get shipped in!
  • Our massive buying power allows us to pass on our savings to you.
  • The best customer support, ongoing and after your project is completed.
  • Over 30 certified and insured installation crews.
  • Crews participate in on-going training to be the best in the city!
  • We’ve been family owned & operated since 1994!

Check out our
Current Specials

Glue Down Vinyl Plank (5mm, 9″)

3 Stock Colors  9" 5mm glue down plank
Read More
Glue Down Vinyl Plank (5mm, 9″)

Glue Down Vinyl Tile (5mm)

2 Stock Colors  12"x24" 5mm glue down vinyl tile
Read More
Glue Down Vinyl Tile (5mm)

Glue Down Vinyl Plank (5mm, 7″)

Your Choice vinyl plank - 10 Stock colors 7" Wide plank 5mm thickness
Read More
Glue Down Vinyl Plank (5mm, 7″)

Curate 7mm Click Vinyl Plank

  Taiga - Curate SPC - 4 Colors Flooring Specifications: Size 9" x 60" / 12" x 24" Thickness 7mm...
Read More
Curate 7mm Click Vinyl Plank

Harmony 6.5mm Click Vinyl Plank

  Harmony 6.5mm - 2 Colors Core:               5mm Pad:           ...
Read More
Harmony 6.5mm Click Vinyl Plank

Evolved – 8mm Click Vinyl

  Evolved - 2 Colors Thickness:     8mm (6.5mm core, 1.5mm pad) Width:            9 5/16”...
Read More
Evolved – 8mm Click Vinyl

Mohawk – Crestview

Crestview 30 oz Everstrand Carpet - 2 colors in inventory
Read More
Mohawk – Crestview

Dreamweaver – Daydream

Daydream 35 oz - Pure Color Poly - 2 colors in inventory
Read More
Dreamweaver – Daydream

Mohawk – Flawless Reputation

Flawless Reputation Patterned SmartStrand Carpet - 2 colors in inventory
Read More
Mohawk – Flawless Reputation

Mohawk – Polished Shades I

Polished Shades I 45oz SmartStrand Tonal - Stocked in 4 Colors
Read More
Mohawk – Polished Shades I